Google TV Review
A few weeks ago I picked up the Logitech Revue. I was excited for the possibilities of Google TV and wanted some new fun gadget to play with. I have some thoughts on the Google TV but before I get there, a bit about my set up and issues along the way. Note that my setup issues mostly had to do with missing hardware and out dated hardware on my end not related to the Google TV.
My previous setup was basic cable, run to multiple pc's networked in the house. Those PC's are all running Windows Media Center (most Windows machines have it). Windows Media Center has been the very best way to have an Internet and DVR home entertainment system set up. The UI has been improved over the years and it works very well. Why Microsoft hasn't promoted the heck out of it I just don't know. It puts everything else to shame. Anyway this is about Google TV, so enough of that.
My TV is actually a Panasonic PT-AX100U projector I picked up a couple years ago. It throws up an 8 foot wide image on my wall. I have it hung from the ceiling, up with it was an Xbox 360, Playstation 3 and a Wii. The Xbox 360 was networked into the home, and streamed live TV and DVR content from any of my machines. It also streamed my music, etc. Worked pretty well too. I didn't have a great way to browse the web from my projector, and the devices were all stacked up on top of the projector, which was entirely unsafe for anyone sitting on the couch underneath.
In order to have my devices down at ground level, and keep the projector up top, I needed new equipment. I decided to go for an HDMI setup. I picked up a receiver (Denon AVR-391) which has 4 HDMI inputs and supports 3D through HDMI. I don't have or care about 3D, but it couldn't hurt to make sure my receiver would support it just in case. It has one HDMI output, so I ran a 50 foot HDMI cable up the ceiling and down to my projector. I then picked up some inexpensive surround sound speakers, mounted everything up and presto.
I then found out my original Xbox 360 doesn't offer HDMI out. DAMN. I don't have many games, but what I do have is almost exclusively for the Xbox 360 including my favorite, which is Rock Band. So new Xbox for me!
Next, I had to set up Dish Network. I wasn't happy with Comcast, and wanted to try something new. Dish Network has special integration in the Google TV as they offer DVR through an integrated UI. So that is what I picked.
A couple tips for those doing similar sort of thing.
1) Not all HDMI cables are the same. Make sure what you get is rated version 1.4a for the 3D support, or at least 1.3 from what I read. This has to do with the kind of data that goes up and down along with the audio and video. I did NOT buy the most expensive. I also bought online and not at Best Buy and other retailers who charge way way to much for those cables.
2) If you run cables along a wall, you are probably going to get some sort of cover for it. The kind I ran had a sticky bottom, and worked really well. My issue was I put it right along a beam on my ceiling. Not a big deal until you want to apply a connector which bridges two pieces. The cover can't wrap around it, as there is no space between your case and the beam. Bah.
3) If you order Dish Network you can also get Google TV via the Logitech Revue. Nobody at Dish Network really understands the Google TV or Logitech Revue gear. They can't actually sell you the Logitech Revue at discount until they already have done the Dish Network install. Yup, they have to come out twice. Plus even if you tell them you are doing Google TV, they may give you an incompatible Dish box, which is what they gave me. I noticed right away and forced them to give me something different. I was lucky they had another option in the van. Double check what kind of Dish receiver you have. Only the 622, 722 and 722k support the special integration to google TV. My Dish installer hadn't even heard of Google TV, and didn't have much interest. I ended up just going to Best Buy to get the Logitech Revue. It was faster to do it this way, and at least I had complete control over the process.
At this point everything worked except my projector showed a massive horizontal bar 8 feet wide that flashed on and off every couple seconds. It did this with all my input sources. At first I thought an issue with my receiver, or maybe my HDMI cable, but after a lot of trial and error, and replacing parts, pieces, I found out that my projector needed a firmware update. Turns out the projector didn't do the HDMI handshake the way that all the newest gear does. This was especially bad with the Dish Network DUO 722k receiver they gave me. Why I can't just update my own firmware, I don't know, so I called Panasonic, which confirmed my issue and I sent it off for repair. It cost $230 plus shipping, but they also replaced some parts. My projector came back working SO MUCH BETTER. I was skeptical, but my HD output from the projector is amazing now.
I also set a google TV in the bedroom for our smaller TV. That was just a direct connection and nothing worth talking about.
So what do I think of the actual Google TV experience? It is a mix of good and bad. The Logitech Revue comes with a very nice keyboard. I like the hardware and everything works just fine. It is light but sturdy and the track pad works just fine as a mouse device.
The OS is weak. I would consider it a .5 beta release really. I am surprised they released it so soon. Must be the holiday sales pressure from the hardware manufacturers.
The OS itself isn't consistent from screen to screen. The back button doesn't always do what you think it will. The search is pretty good, but could be better. Many of the websites for watching your favorite shows have now blocked the Google TV. I expect Google will come up with an arrangement with those stations at some point soon. Personally, it has no effect on my experience, as I have TV and DVR. Others will want the Revue without actually having cable or dish service connected. It just isn't good for TV in that scenario until content providers get on board.
As for the Dish Network integration... it is pretty good. At some points you need to change over to the Dish UI and when you do it is... well it is Dish. Which is to say who the hell built those DVR menus? Fired. All of them. 'Set Timer' is the button which really means 'done' when setting a show to record? Really? Anyway, that isn't part of google TV, and you can use google TV to set DVR instead, which works much better. If you don't have Dish Network, then you just use the regular cable interface when doing functions like DVR. Not really a bad deal, and hopefully there will be more integration with other TV programming providers in the future.
Browsing the Internet works pretty well. The version of Chrome browser seems to be a bit old, which is also surprising. Why not have the latest? Also it gets confusing which trying to change tabs. If you are a power browser surfing on multiple tabs at once then you will be a bit frustrated with the UI. That said, there is something very handy about pausing or putting your TV show in a mini window, then jumping over to the web to do whatever you need. IMDB, weather, email, etc. On my projector it is pretty freaking awesome. You can also play many of the Flash games out there. I haven't found any websites that don't work. Well, that don't work due to a failure. There are sites that block the Google TV and others like Hulu which haven't yet worked out licensing agreements.
One case point for browsing. We had friends over asking about what the Halloween Parade is like in Portsmouth NH. I pressed the search button, typed in Halloween Parade 2009 Portsmouth and before hitting enter had a list of youtube videos to watch. I click on one and presto, full screen youtube of the parade, and my friends in the parade. It was great.
The system comes with a few apps already including Netflix. I am a fan of Netflix and it works just fine, though there is NO search. Really? I would be pretty pissed about this, but I read this morning that an update is about to come out (just a few days) which greatly enhances the experience including search. In the mean time I can just jump over to a browser and search through their regular website and mark what I want for the cue.
And that is the really great part of Google TV. One update has already come out, others are clearly coming. The device will continue to be updated and improved. I can search the web, while watching TV, and feel comfortable that it will be a better and better experience over time.
Not only that, but I can build apps for it, much in the same way people can create apps for Android phone OS (same basic thing). I expect that in 3-4 months there are a huge number of apps to pick from. App development is something I haven't started yet, however I know that you can do it with Adobe AIR platform. If you can create something in Flash/Actionscript, you can make Google TV apps. I am sure you can also make native apps in Java as well. As of this blog post, development isn't available for the masses. They say early 2011, so hopefully it isn't too long.
Bottom line for Google TV: If you want perfection, there isn't any device out there that provides it yet. Just wait. If you like new tech, grab the Review. It is inexpensive ($300), works pretty well and the future looks bright. Just beware there are some hiccups along the way and if you want to watch TV on it, you still need dish or cable service. Lets all hope that gets sorted out in 2011.
For some fun, here is the latest advertisement. Rather funny in my opinion, and shows the Google TV in action a bit.


